A Vision So Noble

HOME > REVIEWS > BOYD BOOKS

Was John Boyd a new Sun Tzu?

A Vision So Noble
A Vision So Noble: John Boyd, the OODA Loop, and America's War on Terror (Daniel Ford)

Could we have gotten inside OBL's OODA Loop? Here's the little book that came out of my graduate studies at King's College London, in which I rummaged through John Boyd's life and writings to find out whether and how his thinking could be applied to the War on Terror. Does it work? Better than you might think, though the 'takeaway' might strike you as disappointing: If it works, it's obsolete . Now available as a 74-page paperback under the title A Vision So Noble and also in a Kindle edition for reading on Amazon's e-book reader, Apple iPad or iPhone, or your Mac or Windows desktop. Read more about this monograph here.

Aerial Attack Study
Aerial Attack Study: Fighter vs Bomber, Fighter vs Fighter
(Captain John Boyd)

This is the monograph Boyd wrote in 1961--the first formulation of the Energy Maneuverability principle that became the basis of aerial combat doctrine in all western air forces. It's also one of the very few documents that Boyd committed to paper. A 156-page PDF file of the original mimeographed study, it's a two-dollar download from Lulu.com.


Boyd: The Fighter Pilot Who Changed the Art of War
(Robert Coram)

I hugely enjoyed this biography, though bothered by the fact that it's completely unsourced. (There's a bibliography, but no footnotes or endnotes to tell us which of this material was used where.) The biography, though a very good read, had the paradoxical effect of making me more skeptical about Boyd. Is Robert Coram perhaps a smoother Martin Caiden? For example: "What [Boyd] discovered late one night in the second-floor classroom of an old building [at Georgia Tech] is as fundamental and as significant to aviation as Newton was to physics" (p.127). Hmm. That, as one of my tutors rebuked me last year, might be described as "rather over-egging the pudding."


The Mind of War: John Boyd and American Security
(Grant Hammond)

This biography doesn't read as easily as Coram's, it's a bit short on Boyd's personal life, and Hammond too is a card-carrying member of the Boyd cult. But (as befits a Smithsonian Book) he's a whole lot clearer on the theory behind energy maneuverability, the OODA Loop, and the 13-hour briefing known as "A Discourse on Winning and Losing."


Science, Strategy and War: The Strategic Theory of John Boyd
(Frans Osinga)

And here's the text for the serious student. Osinga was a Dutch military pilot who wrote his doctoral dissertation on John Boyd. This book was the result. It's hard going, and rather circular (like the OODA Loop itself), but it's the closest thing we have to the book that John Boyd never wrote. The briefing slides are quoted verbatim and at length, so all you're missing is the Mad Major himself, standing on the balls of his fee and hectoring you for hours. Also available in a very expensive hardcover.


A Swift, Elusive Sword: What if Sun Tzu and John Boyd Did a National Defense Review?
(Chet Richards)

This is an interesting piece of work, by one of the tenders of the Boyd flame. Mr Richards runs the Defense in the National Interest website, which is a blog-plus-library of stuff directly and indirectly related to John Boyd. Here he uses Sun-tzu's and Boyd's writings to figure out what kind of a US military they would build if they had a chance to start from scratch. (For openers: get rid of the Army combat units! The Marines can do it better.) A bit pricey, but what can you do?


The John Boyd Roundtable: Debating Science, Strategy,and War
(Mark Safranski, editor)

Also expensive ($25 is the price we pay for specializing in a field where not many dare tread!) is this large-format paperback from Nimble Books. It consists of essays originally posted online by a clutch of scholars, writers, and military men, and revised and expanded for publication. One of them is Frans Osinga, and several of the contributors have as much to say about the "colonel-doctor" as about Boyd himself. Well worth a browse.

When Sun-tzu met Clausewitz
When Sun-tzu met Clausewitz
(Daniel Ford)

This is my 'long essay' for Strategic Dimensions in Contemporary Warfare at King's College London (now incorporated in A Vision So Noble above.) It's a two-dollar download from Lulu.com, which publishes e-books in PDF format for easy reading on a computer monitor. It's also available for Amazon's Kindle reader. Click here for more.

Question? Comment? Newsletter? Send me an email. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford

Michael's
War
Michael's War: Two rebels in the County Cork, 1916-1923 (fiction) Paperback or Kindle edition.
Incident at Muc
Wa
Incident at Muc Wa: The Vietnam novel that inspired the acclaimed Burt Lancaster movie, Go Tell the Spartans. In paperback or as a Kindle edition.

The Only
War We've Got
The Only War We've Got: A reporter's journal: the Vietnam War before it all went sour. Paperback or Kindle edition.

Poland's Daughter
Poland's Daughter - How I Met Basia, Hitchhiked to Italy, and Learned About Love, War, and Exile. Paperback or Kindle edition.

Flying Tigers: Claire Chennault and His American Volunteers, 1941-1942
Flying Tigers: Claire Chennault and His American Volunteers: "Every page contains a new tidbit of information and rich, long-forgotten detail."

Glen Edwards
Glen Edwards: The Diary of a Bomber Pilot - Fifty missions over North Africa--and a fiery death in the desert. Paperback or Kindle edition.

Remains: a story of the Flying Tigers
Remains: a story of the Flying Tigers: "A cracking good yarn" (Air&Space magazine)

Lady & the Tigers
The Lady and the Tigers: Olga Greenlaw's 1942 account of her year with the Flying Tigers in Burma and China. Paperback or Kindle edition.

The High Country Illuminator
The High Country Illuminator: A tale of light and darkness and the ski bums of Avalon (fiction). Paperback or Kindle edition.